Pesticides: What is the Real Cost for Health?

France is currently one of the leading global users of pesticides in agriculture. Yet, nobody is currently in a position to assess the human health cost of the massive use of pesticides in agriculture. This situation is even more surprising given that the dangers of pesticides have long been studied by the two disciplines that are central to the field of environmental health: toxicology and epidemiology.

Jean-Noël Jouzel, CNRS research fellow at the Centre for the Sociology of Organisations, discusses his findings in his article in Cogito, our research newsletter: Short summary 

Evidence on the effects of pesticides provided by toxicology and epidemiology is at times highly contradictory. Toxicology, uses laboratory testing on mice to evaluate the relative dangers posed by substances within pesticides. Whereas epidemiology measures how exposure to pesticides in the real world is dangerous by measuring environmental factors. 

For any manufacturer who wishes to put a pesticide into the market, their substance must undergo toxicity testing. Toxicology identifies a dose which is deemed acceptable by individually testing the effects of each substance contained in the pesticide. However, the truth is that humans do not live or work in a sterile laboratory. Farmworkers, who are at highest risk of exposure to pesticides, come into contact with a variety of different substances in different concentrations. There is thus a sort of cocktail effect in which farmworkers ingest many different substances simultaneously, and it is the interaction of these substances which toxicology fails to account for. Epidemiology, however, studies the effects of pesticides on exposed populations. Epidemiological research, in contrast to toxicology reports, shows strong links between pesticide exposure and chronic diseases.

Fresh Growth for Pesticide Research

Why then, you may ask, is epidemiological research not favoured over toxicology? The main problem faced by epidemiologists is that exposed populations represent very small samples. Comparative to toxicology, epidemiology is unable to produce statistical evidence on a large scale. It is thus very easily dismissed. For this reason, risk assessment models are almost solely based on toxicological studies. 

However, positive advances are on the horizon; for example the Environmental Protection Agency in the United States (EPA) and of the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) in the European Union are incorporating epidemiological studies into the development of pesticides. Yet, for the time being toxicology prevails as the pesticide oracle. If policy-makers truly want to improve the health of exposed populations they should abandon a substance-by-substance approach, and adopt a holistic view of pesticide exposure. 

Read the full article here

Other articles by Jean-Noël Jouzel: Becoming a Victim of Pesticides: Legal Action and Its Effects on the Mobilisation of Affected Farmworkers

Sign up to Cogito

Sign up to our newsletters

Back to School 2021: Welcome to our new Undergraduate College students!

Back to School 2021: Welcome to our new Undergraduate College students!

It’s back to school across Sciences Po’s campuses: this time in person, without capacity restrictions! The Undergraduate College is delighted to welcome its 4,626 students (all three years included) for the start of the academic year 2021-2022. We spoke to new and returning students, all of whom were enthusiastic to be on campus kickstarting an exciting year.

More
“Building Sustainable Development for the 21st Century” : an inspiring lecture by Nicholas Stern

“Building Sustainable Development for the 21st Century” : an inspiring lecture by Nicholas Stern

On 24 August, incoming students of Sciences Po’s School of Management and Innovation were invited to an inaugural lecture by Sir Nicholas Stern, director of the Grantham Institute for Climate Change and the Environment (LSE) and author of the Stern Review on the Economics of Climate Change. The conference, centering on the theme “Building Sustainable Development for the 21st Century: Policies, Institutions, Behaviour, Collaborations”, was an opportunity to welcome the students to the challenges and fundamental issues they will tackle during their studies and in their professional careers.

More
Pedagogic innovation in the pandemic: New opportunities in hybrid teaching

Pedagogic innovation in the pandemic: New opportunities in hybrid teaching

Enjoying a return to face-to-face classes, while harnessing the digital tools and experience gained during the pandemic: this is the pedagogic opportunity offering itself to many faculty members at the start of the new academic year. Gaspard Estrada, the Executive Director of Sciences Po’s Political Observatory of Latin America and the Caribbean (OPALC) (fr), is no newcomer to hybrid teaching. He experimented in the format last semester for his course “How to conquer, govern, and quit power: methods and practice of political communication”, a module on political communication offered to students of the Master in Advanced Global Studies at PSIA in May 2021. Estrada told us more about his dynamic course, which was enriched by the new possibilities opened up by hybrid teaching.

More
1 Saint Thomas : only a few months until Sciences Po's new site opens its doors

1 Saint Thomas : only a few months until Sciences Po's new site opens its doors

Begun in September 2018, the renovations of Sciences Po’s newest site at 1 Place Saint Thomas d'Aquin have continued throughout the pandemic. The premises will soon become a central hub of the university’s Paris Campus. Ahead of their much-awaited opening this November, with the first classes to be held onsite from the start of 2022, we caught up with director of real estate Emmanuelle Dubrana. 

More
The Other Europe: a unique story

The Other Europe: a unique story

1986. For a year, Mikhail Gorbachev, General Secretary of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union, has been trying to reform the system. An unprecedented experiment, perestroika is observed, with hope or scepticism, by the whole world. With eyes riveted on Moscow, interest in the "sister countries" - nearly 15 nations that joined the USSR - was almost non-existent.

More