Investigating Street Art in Latin America

Political scientist Olivier Dabène is the author of Street Art and Democracy in Latin America, published by Palgrave Macmillan. In this interview, the author presents the results of a several year long project in multiple cities of Latin America, during which he investigated and questioned the relationship between street art and (local) democracy. 

This interview was conducted by Miriam Perier and originally published on the Centre for International Studies (CERI) website. 

What triggered your interest in street art?

My book finds its origin in a two-year stay in São Paulo, Brazil, in 2000-2002. My research interests back then focused on democracy operating at the local level under very adverse background conditions including very high levels of violence and abysmal inequalities. As I was exploring some of the most deprived areas of the city, I soon discovered they were home to amazing artistic creativity. I started to study the way disenfranchised groups used arts to voice their frustration and nurture public debates. Rap music and marginal literature turned out to be the subject of a book (Exclusion et politique à São Paulo: Les outsiders de la démocratie au Brésil published with Karthala in 2006) while other fascinating politicised artistic expressions such as graffiti writing were temporarily put on the back burner. After a decade exploring other topics, I let my fascination for urban culture regain preeminence with a new comparative research project on street art and democracy.

What is or are the core argument(s) of this book?

The core argument of this book is twofold. First, when artists invade public space for the sake of voicing rage and disseminating claims or statements, they raise public awareness, nurture public debate, and hold authorities accountable. They can also interact with neighbours and thereby contribute to community building. Consequently, so goes my argument, they behave as urban citizens and foster street-level deliberative democracy even if they violate the law on a regular basis. Second, street art reveals how public space is governed. When local authorities try to contain, regulate, and monitor, or even repress, public space invasions, they can achieve their goals democratically if, instead of simply criminalising the activity, they engage in dialogue with the artists and try to reach an understanding inspired by a conception of the city as a commons.

Street art by Lapiztola

"Real Democracy Now" (© Lapiztola)

How did you work, what research methodology did you adopt? How did you choose the sites you investigated and the artists you interviewed?

I conducted a total of 63 interviews in five Latin American cities, in order to collect empirical evidence and prepare to undertake in-depth city case studies. The five cities examined in this book were selected because they were more or less distant from the democratic ideal-type that rests upon two overlapping and cross-fertilising components: urban-citizen artists strengthening street-level democracy and authorities keen to deliberate over the use of public space and promote urban collaborative governance. My “anchor” case was Bogota (Colombia) and then came São Paulo (Brazil), Valparaíso (Chile), Oaxaca (México), and Havana (Cuba).

Is there a contradiction—for street artists, according to you—between the fact of acting as urban citizens and violating the law on a regular basis?

Violating the law is an act of defiance that entails a political meaning. Most of the artists I interviewed explained they had a message to convey and chose to do it by intervening on a wall, at the risk of being taken into custody!

To me, street artists qualify as urban citizens if/when they make public claims about issues of common concern. Legality is not a factor. I admit this is debatable, but I deliberately put the emphasis on empowerment, that is on disenfranchised categories forcing their way into the “demos”. In my view, deliberative democracy can accommodate some illegal expressions.

Pixação in Sao Paolo

Pixação in Sao Paolo (Photo by Olivier Dabène)

In what way does street art reveal how public space is governed? Why does it reveal the city as a commons?

You can tell by looking at city walls if municipal authorities are keen to tolerate or even incentivise some forms of street art or if they rush to refurbish the walls. Then, on further inquiry, you can unveil several types of interactions between artists and authorities. I was particularly interested in cooperative governance, when artists and authorities open a space of deliberation and try to find common ground and set some rules, inspired by a conception of the city as belonging to all (commons).

Did this project bring about surprises?

I knew beforehand that street artists had many stories to tell about politics. However, the field work delivered more than expected: daring artists intervening on walls downtown Havana, for instance. I did not expect to meet so many artists making public claims in Cuba.

Still, more than surprises, what this project brought about were fascinating encounters. I really enjoyed doing my field work. Our conversations were fluid and we were able to get to the bottom of their urge to share emotions.

Comments on some selected works

Street art can contribute to opinion formation and hence to deliberative democracy. Here are three examples.

Stencil in Havana

A stencil of Fidel Castro in Havana, Cuba (artist unknown)

In Havana (Cuba), I found this stencil of Fidel Castro with a simple arithmetic below it: 90+. Some people probably interpreted the message as a reminder that their cherished líder máximo was getting very old, a worry converted into sadness and nostalgia after he died in 2017. Others probably silently lamented the fact that he led the destiny of their country for so long, even from the back seat in his last years. Be it a tribute or a critique, there is no way to know what the artist meant, but there is every reason to believe that everyone felt concerned and comforted in his opinion.

Stencil in San José par Yamil de la Paz Garcia

"Imagine San José without window bars" (© Yamil de la Paz García)

In San José (Costa Rica), I met street artist Yamil de la Paz García, who disseminated a stencil saying “Imagine San José without window bars.” Yamil’s injunction to imagine a different city sounds like a challenge for the urban dwellers used to navigating in an environment perceived as hostile. Yet, significantly, Yamil is not trying to impose his personal opinion. And this is where he behaves as an urban citizen, inviting his fellow-citizens to reconsider their conceptions of the city, be part of public debates on insecurity, and make up their judgment and policy preferences. To some extent, his invitation to “imagine” is neutral. Some would interpret it as an evocation of a golden era when there was more sociability in the streets and neighbourhoods. By contrast, others would picture a nightmarish future during which the inhabitants are unable to protect themselves from petty crimes.

Artwork by Lapiztola

The work of Lapiztola in Oaxaca (© Lapiztola)

In Oaxaca (México), I am a great admirer of Lapiztola, a crew composed of two artists, Rosario and Roberto.

This piece is quite emblematic of their undertaking, with several layers of meaning using symbols and a particular attention paid to details.

An indigenous girl chasing a pig with her mother watching, out of necessity to find food? It is much more complex than the impression at first sight. The girl is actually trying to tattoo the pig, which could evoke a mark of private property, much like rich land-owners do with their cattle. Yet, it appears even richer, as the details reveal the girl herself has two tattoos on her right arm. One says “union and strength” and the other represents a bird with the word libre (free). And the pig actually has two tattoos as well, one that displays a wing and a flower with an ironic “viva la vida”, and another one representing the Eye of Providence. There are also several wounds on the pig’s skin, which can be interpreted as previous failed tattooing attempts.

In a conversation with Rosario, she proved to not have all the answers. Some meanings must remain unexplained, she said. They just let their imagination take control… and let the viewers react.

More information

Goodbye Plastic, Hello Koovee

Goodbye Plastic, Hello Koovee

A committed ecologist and graduate of Sciences Po in 2015, Tiphaine Guerout has channeled her entrepreneurial ambition towards an environmental cause. She is the founder of Koovee, a startup that offers an alternative to disposable plastic cutlery: forks and spoons made of biscuit, made in France, that have the particularity of being sufficiently resistant so that one can eat with them. Interview with a young graduate who hopes to flood the French and European markets in the years to come.

More

A New Online Campus Starting Fall 2020

A New Online Campus Starting Fall 2020

After a successful online spring 2020 semester despite an unprecedented emergency context, the start of the 2020/2021 academic year will allow all of our students to embark on a new year at Sciences Po in a safe and serene manner. With both physical campuses and an all-new digital campus available to them, courses have been redesigned to best suit all students.

More
Prof. Sébastien Treyer: European Environmental Policies

Prof. Sébastien Treyer: European Environmental Policies

“Restrictions”, “trade-offs”, and “frustrations”: environmental politics can feel like an uphill battle. But there is ever reason to keep climbing! While we may not be able to transform our power plants overnight, we have the power to drive forward our institutions in the fight against climate change. Pause the glossy reports and press play on action: for Professor Sébastien Treyer, sustainable development can take many possible routes, and is full of promise.

More
Where are our graduates now?

Where are our graduates now?

The 2020 Graduate Employability Survey asked the Class of 2018 what they were up to now. Their responses reaffirm Sciences Po graduates’ attractivity on the job market, with 9 out of 10 graduates currently working. Amongst them, 86% landed a job less than 6 months after graduating, and ¾ of them in a permanent contract. More and more graduates work abroad (37%), and more and more report being satisfied with their jobs! Discover the full results of our survey below.

More
LSE becomes the eighth full member of CIVICA

LSE becomes the eighth full member of CIVICA

On 16 June 2020, the European Commission updated the status of The London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE) from “associated partner” to “full member” of CIVICA - The European University of Social Sciences, following a request submitted by the alliance.

More
Key takeaways from a semester unlike any other

Key takeaways from a semester unlike any other

The 2019/2020 academic year has come to an end, and our students have experienced a semester unlike any other. What takeaways can we draw from this unprecedented period? How did this hurried switchover go over for students and teachers? The verdict that we are able to draw today shows a successful adjustment for the vast majority and provides useful lessons for the upcoming semester.

More
Prof. Anne Cullerre: “Ruling the seas”

Prof. Anne Cullerre: “Ruling the seas”

Students both with and without previous military experience are able to enrol in Vice-Admiral Anne Cullerre’s course, “Ruling the seas”, provided that they have an interest in the “untamable realm” that is the ocean, with all of its geopolitical rivalries, territorial disputes, environmental challenges...and pirates. While “a smooth sea never made a skilled sailor”, a skilled sailor certainly makes a great teacher!

More
A Deep Dive Into the Heart of the Startup Nation

A Deep Dive Into the Heart of the Startup Nation

After a trip to Silicon Valley in 2017 and to the MIT in 2019, the Centre for Entrepreneurship’s third Learning Expedition took participants to Israel, a country equivalent in size to a French département that has the highest number of startups per capita in the world (1 in 6,000). What are the reasons for this “entrepreneurial miracle”, and how does it work? Loanne Guérin and Laura Salesse (first and second year students respectively in the Master’s in Finance and Strategy), two of the twelve students chosen to take part in the adventure, tell us about their experience.

More
Mobility as a Catalyst for Resilience and Renewal

Mobility as a Catalyst for Resilience and Renewal

International academic mobility has been a cornerstone of universities dating back as far as the 12th and 13th centuries when they began to flower throughout the European continent.  With a clear understanding of the multiple benefits of academic mobility and the rich and diverse learning environment it created, the University of Bologna, the oldest university in Europe, adopted the Constitutio Habita, an academic charter that ensured and protected the rights and free movement of a traveling scholar in the pursuit of education.  The widely referred to concept of “academic freedom” today stems from the idea of this charter.

More
Basic Relationships Between Epidemic, Economy, and Inequalities

Basic Relationships Between Epidemic, Economy, and Inequalities

The public debate on the current economic crisis and the COVID-19 pandemic has focused on rich countries. But how is this crisis truly “global”? What are the current inequalities with developing countries? Here is an overview with Jérôme Sgard, Professor of Political Economy at the Centre for International Studies (CERI) at Sciences Po and specialist in the construction and regulation of markets.

More