How financialization has driven an increase in inequality across the world

The modern era has witnessed a dramatic increase in wage inequality across the developed world since the late 1990s. While previous assumptions might have predicted that Europe could resist such forces, Sciences Po researcher Olivier Godechot of MaxPo and the OSC finds that France, too, has fallen prey to increasing inequality.

His research shows that finance professionals are largely to blame and can be justifiably seen as the “bad guys” who hold financial firms hostage by demanding large bonuses, threatening to move key assets to competitors if they do not get what they want.
 
Interview with Olivier Godechot, author of Financialization Is Marketization! A Study of the Respective Impacts of Various Dimensions of Financialization on the Increase in Global Inequality.

What do you mean by “financialization” and why is it important?

Olivier Godechot: The concept of financialization is multi-dimensional. It can refer to the growth of the financial sector as a whole, or of financial market activities only, or go beyond the finance sector to the financialization of non-financial institutions, firms or households. I show that when measured through its impact on inequality, financialization is primarily a phenomenon of marketization, which I propose to define as the increase in social activity devoted to trade in securities on financial markets. Contrary to previous scholarship inspired by Marxist or heterodox economics, which generally focused on macro-social mechanisms in terms of financial regimes, power resources, and global bargaining power, I try to go further by pinning down the precise mechanisms at stake within the financial labor market. 

Has inequality been on the rise only in “Anglo-liberal” economies, or is continental Europe affected too

OG: With the complete individual wage data that I used in my article, it is possible to assess the development of inequality in France very accurately, and to break it down so as to measure the part played by finance. Contrary to the view put forward by social scientists, who generally consider France to be a good example of stability in inequality over the last 30 years, the data show a sharp surge at the very top of the wage distribution in the mid-1990s. The top 0.1 percent increased its share of the total wage bill by 0.85 percentage point, moving up to 1.1 percent in 1996 and 1.95 percent in 2007. Half of this increase is for the top 0.01 percent.

Which sectors accounted for most of the increase in inequality? 

OG: In order to break down this increase in inequality, I calculated the evolution of the overall wage share of France’s top 0.1 percent of earners, working in finance, service to business, entertainment, and other sectors. I found that finance contributed 48 percent of the rise in the share of the top 0.1 percent, whereas service to business and other sectors each contributed just under 23 percent, and entertainment only 8 percent. When moving into the top 0.01 percent, I found that finance made a 57-percent contribution to the increase in the share of the working rich. The impact of finance on the increase of the top 1 percent remains high, with a contribution of around 40 percent.

Which aspect of financialization had the largest effect on growing inequality in your study?

OG: When I broke down the financial sector effect, I found that the increase in inequality was mainly driven by the increase in the volume of stocks traded in national stock exchanges and by the volume of shares held as assets in banks’ balance sheets. On the other hand, the financialization of non-financial firms and households does not play a significant role.

So what can we make of the popular response to the effects that you show in your research?

OG: The “Occupy” movement of 2011, which condemned inequalities with the slogan “We are the 99 percent” and occupied sites that symbolised financial power (Zuccotti Park next to Wall Street, Saint Paul’s cathedral in London, La Défense in Paris), was ultimately “right” to target finance as the catalyst and main symbol of the contemporary rise in inequality. My analysis clearly shows that finance has contributed heavily to this rise. Finance encourages polarisation in financial firms and the financial sector as a whole, in global financial cities, between these cities and the rest of their respective countries, in national economies and between these economies. As such, it constitutes a threat to social cohesion. Of all the risks incurred by the payment of bonuses in finance, the social risk is no doubt the most overlooked but certainly not the least important.

Finally, much has been made of the “bad guys” who are thought to hold the most responsibility for the growth of inequality. Can you tell us how this works?

OG: The link between finance and inequality is mainly due to the appearance of a rent on the financial markets and its appropriation by a minority. Its unequal distribution is now well understood. While some scholars try to explain high bonuses with the theory of superstars and winner-take-all phenomena, I have shown that finance professionals also have a hold over financial firms. They can effectively threaten to move key assets to competitors. However, the emergence of the global financial rent still needs further exploration. The financial deregulation of the past thirty years, which has created new markets, is probably one of its major drivers.
 
Related links

Goodbye Plastic, Hello Koovee

Goodbye Plastic, Hello Koovee

A committed ecologist and graduate of Sciences Po in 2015, Tiphaine Guerout has channeled her entrepreneurial ambition towards an environmental cause. She is the founder of Koovee, a startup that offers an alternative to disposable plastic cutlery: forks and spoons made of biscuit, made in France, that have the particularity of being sufficiently resistant so that one can eat with them. Interview with a young graduate who hopes to flood the French and European markets in the years to come.

More

University Consortium: Scientific Dialogue Between the US, Europe and Russia

University Consortium: Scientific Dialogue Between the US, Europe and Russia

In April 2019, Sciences Po became a member of the University Consortium, a project created in 2015 following the observation of the decline in academic expertise on Russia in the West and the renewal of tensions in East-West relations. The University Consortium was effectively born out of the desire to create a space for dialogue and common reflection on the security issues in the Euro-Atlantic zone at a moment where relations between Russia, Europe and the US are in crisis and marked by a strong diplomatic, media and ideological polarisation.

More
Dealing with Climate Change on Small Islands

Dealing with Climate Change on Small Islands

Why are small islands more vulnerable to the global and major ordeal of climate change? How do they face this huge challenge and what can we learn from their experience? These are among the crucial questions examined by Carola Klöck and Michael Fink in their recently coedited volume entitled Dealing with Climate Change on Small Islands: Toward Effective and Sustainable Adaptation, published by Universitätsverlag Göttingen.

This interview was originally published on the CERI website.

More
French Graduate Admissions: Tips for the Interview

French Graduate Admissions: Tips for the Interview

Have you applied for a master’s programme at Sciences Po via the French procedure*? If you successfully pass through the first phase of the application process – results of which are announced from 23 March 2020 onwards – you will move on to the second phase of the application process: the interview. This final stage of the admissions procedure will take place between the end of April and the start of May 2020. For many students, the interview can be the most stressful element of their application: what kind of profile are we looking for, how can you demonstrate your motivation, how best defend your ideas? Preparation is key! That is why we’ve laid out some simple guidelines to help get you onto the home straight.

More
Summer School: Admissions are open

Summer School: Admissions are open

The Summer School is an opportunity for students from around the world to discover Sciences Po over the course of a summer on our Paris and Reims campuses.  Here’s what you need to know before starting your application!

More
Justice in Civil War Contexts

Justice in Civil War Contexts

Adam Baczko conducts research on the formation of legal institutions by armed movements and international actors in contexts of armed conflict, with a particular focus on Afghanistan and Syria. Adam joined CERI as CNRS researcher in September 2019.

Interview conducted by Corinne Deloy and translated into English by Miriam Perier and Caitlin Gordon Walker (CERI).

More
How much is tuition at Sciences Po?

How much is tuition at Sciences Po?

At Sciences Po, we believe that financial barriers should never get in the way of education. Tuition fees are relatively lower than other world-class universities because of our proactive social policy to be an open and inclusive university. Please note: the following tuition rates are for the 2019-2020 academic year.

More