Colours, Smells, Soles of Shoes: The Slippery Slope of Trademarking

What do Rubix Cubes, Kit-Kat bars, Pantone 1837, Louboutin shoes, the smell of Play-Doh, and the decor of the Apple Store have in common? All have been the subject of heated legal debate to determine whether these non-traditional brand markers should be granted the status of regular trademarks. This week, Sciences Po welcomed academics and lawyers involved in the debate for a conference on ‘The Protection of Non-Conventional Trademarks’. The event marked the forthcoming publication of a collection of essays on the subject by intellectual property experts, Professors Irene Calboli and Martin Senftleben.

Attendees first heard from Calboli, who discussed the detrimental implications of trigger-happy trademark registration on the market. Where does the line fall between defending a firm’s right to protect its brand identity and allowing it to exercise a monopoly? Calboli stressed the “chilling effect” that excessive trademarks can have on creativity and competition in the market, resulting in reduced incentives for productivity and investment, all while increasing the cost of products themselves. Her conclusion from a public policy standpoint: we should not protect more than is strictly necessary.

“What is a mark? It’s a very very large definition with a very low threshold to prove distinctiveness. We need to avoid descending into a slippery slope where anything that is deemed original or eye-catching can meet the grade for distinctiveness and thus be registered as a mark.”

Senftleben approached the issue from a cultural perspective, addressing the overlaps between copyright and trademark law. While the expiry date of copyright allows intellectual property to pass into and enhance the public domain, registered trademarks risk freezing the “raw materials for cultural creativity” in perpetuity. The moment a character, colour, smell, shape, pattern is fixed as a trademark it can no longer be a source of creative inspiration. Focussing on the example of attempts by the city of Oslo to register two of their most famous cultural monuments as trademarks, Senftleben warned against the particular potential of non-traditional marks to infringe on artistic freedom.

Calboli and Senftleben’s interventions were followed by a panel discussion with two trademark lawyers, as well as members of the audience. The event was organised and moderated by Sciences Po’s own intellectual property expert, Professor Séverine Dusollier.

Related links

Breaking the Glass Ceiling: Gender Equality in Politics

Breaking the Glass Ceiling: Gender Equality in Politics

Following the recent launch of the Certificate for Gender Equality, or “Certificat egalité femmes-hommes” at Sciences Po, the Founder and Executive Director of the Women and Public Policy Program (WAPPP) at the Harvard Kennedy School of Government, Victoria Budson, came to lecture on women in U.S. politics. She was joined by Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, former French Minister of Women’s Affairs, and first French woman to be appointed Minister of Education and Research.

More
HeForShe: Universities & Corporations Hand In Hand

HeForShe: Universities & Corporations Hand In Hand

Sciences Po joined the HeforShe movement in June 2015, when Frédéric Mion became the only IMPACT 10x10x10 champion at a French university. On the 3rd April 2019, Sciences Po hosted a HeforShe panel discussion with various champions to talk about change at an institutional level, share the progress made, and pass on the baton to the younger generation in the battle for gender equality. 

More
The Art and Success of Sciences Po's Debate Team

The Art and Success of Sciences Po's Debate Team

Sciences Po students love to debate, and therefore it is no surprise that Sciences Po has numerous debate clubs, workshops, and even a debate team. What is perhaps more surprising is that the Sciences Po Debate team debates in English, using British Parliamentary style. This year, for the 26th Edition of the annual French Debating Association Tournament, Sciences Po made it all the way to the finals - losing against the Ecole Polytechnique. 

More
Talent meets Opportunity at the 2019 European Internships Forum

Talent meets Opportunity at the 2019 European Internships Forum

Every year, Sciences Po students interested in European internships or careers have the opportunity to attend the European Internships Forum which takes place in Brussels, jointly organized by Sciences Po, LSE (London School of Economics), and the College of Europe. Watch the video to see what students gained from the internship fair. 

More
10 years, 100 startups

10 years, 100 startups

Over 100 startups incubated, 1,000 businesses created, annual sales turnovers of tens of millions of euros, and resales worth hundreds of millions...These are the outstanding results of the Sciences Po Incubator on its 10th birthday, celebrated this year. 

It was a pioneering scheme whose structure was one of the very first to be created at a university in the field of social sciences and humanities. We take a look back at the incubator over its 10 years with Maxime Marzin, Head of the Centre for Entrepreneurship at Sciences Po, who helped to set it up. More

Poitiers: 5 Surprising Things About Our New Campus

Poitiers: 5 Surprising Things About Our New Campus

Since 2001 Sciences Po has had a campus in Poitiers, but the undergraduate college was pushed for space at the Hôtel Chaboureau. There was a 15% increase in students in the space of 5 years, with the attractiveness of the Latin-American programme making new premises necessary. This became a reality in September 2018 at the heart of a new site built in the 18th century and reinvented for the 21st. Watch the guided tour on the occasion of the official inauguration which takes places on Wednesday, 10th April.

More
Furthering Collaboration With The University of Cambridge

Furthering Collaboration With The University of Cambridge

Earlier this week, Sciences Po welcomed Vice-Chancellor of the University of Cambridge, Professor Stephen Toope, who came to exchange with President Frédéric Mion about the current partnership and collaboration between the two universities. A new Memorandum of Understanding was signed to further strengthen collaboration at the research and doctoral levels.

More