A Groundswell of Protest in Latin America

Olivier Dabène is a Professor of Political Science and a Senior Researcher at the Center for International Studies (CERI), Sciences Po. His research focuses on the state of democracy and regional integration in Latin America.

The notion of a “Latin American Spring” popularized by the media undoubtedly reflects the acceleration of mobilizations in this region in 2019, but it exaggerates its singularity. Latin America has seen massive demonstrations develop since at least 2012, reflecting a transformation of the forms of expression in the continent’s democracies.

Over the last ten years indeed, street demonstrations have become a “normal” form of expression that compensates for the limits of representative and participatory systems. Surveys show an increase in the number of people who report participation in demonstrations and tolerating peaceful “anti-system” expressions. This development is particularly noticeable among people with a high level of education. [1]

Examples of mass mobilizations since 2012

Year

Country

Cause/reason

2012

Mexico

Support of 131 students who oppose the candidacy of Peña Nieto (#YoSoy132)

2013

Brazil

Rise of price of bus ticket (Pase libre)

2014

Mexico

Violence (#YaMeCansé)

2015

Guatemala

Corruption (#RenunciaYa)

2015

Argentina

Femicides (#NiUnaMenos)

2016

Brazil

President Rousseff destitution

2017

Honduras

Electoral fraud

2017

Venezuela

Authoritarian drift

2018

Peru

Fall in price of agricultural products

2019

Ecuador

Rise in gas price

2019

Chile

Rise of price of metro ticket

2019

Bolivia

Electoral fraud

2019

Colombia

Pension system reform

As the above list indicates, the major demonstrations have been launched in response to various reasons for dissatisfaction, which can be grouped into three categories: political (rigged elections, corrupt or incompetent leaders, authoritarian drift); economic (threatened purchasing power); and societal (violence against students and women). At a more local level, Latin America is also characterized by a very high level of social mobilization focused on socio-environmental issues.

The demonstrations share a number of common features:

  • The nature of the trigger (rise in gas price or electoral fraud for example) makes it impossible to predict the causes that will then be defended during protests. The major events are in fact characterized by an aggregation of sometimes scattered claims that echo each other.
  •  Since 2012, the occupation of the streets has given rise to scenes of violence unseen since the return of democracies some 40 years ago.

  • In some cases this violence is the result of provocations by radicalized groups. But it is above all the product of a militarization of the work of the police, which gives additional reasons for demonstrating.

  • Physical violence relays activism on social networks (WhatsApp in particular). Despite the success of some online campaigns (Argentina holds the world record for “victories” by users on the www.change.org platform), the physical occupation of urban spaces remains strategic. It includes an efflorescence of artistic expression. The performance called Un violador en tu camino, performed by Chilean women, has been seen hundreds of thousands of times on social networks and has been replicated in many countries and languages around the world.

  • The participants in the events belong to very young age groups. In particular, adolescent girls are at the forefront of feminist commitments in several Latin American countries.

La Paz Bolivia 12 July 2015

How Can These Evolutions be Explained?

In-depth qualitative studies will clarify the types of explanations that are better able to account for these mobilizations, but for the time being, two approaches may be singled out:

  • The Context: Frustration among the Middle Class

Since the Davies J-curve,[2] many observers have sought to attribute the origin of the mobilizations to a sudden interruption of social progress following a long period of growth that had raised the population’s expectations. Latin America has indeed experienced a decade of growth that ended in 2013, closing an exceptional surge of citizen inclusion. Since then, all surveys show that public opinion is concerned. In Brazil, for example, the proportion of respondents who consider the country’s economic situation to be bad has risen from 35% in 2012 to 87% in 2015.[3] In a phase of decline, social inequalities are no longer tolerated, and the fear of social downgrading predisposes certain categories to mobilize. The demonstrations do not particularly affect countries where the middle classes are the most vulnerable, however. Chile has even seen inequalities fall steadily since 2000.[4]

  • Contempt for class, race, and gender

Beyond contextual explanations linked to the economic situation, the demonstrations highlight forms of discontent that have remained dormant until now. The human dimension of inequalities outweighs pecuniary considerations. A demand for respect for human dignity runs through the marches. The demonstrators want to put an end to the contempt for class, race, and gender that characterizes Latin American societies.

The sense of injustice focuses on access to education and health, which alone can offer opportunities for sustainable progress to the younger generations.

What Can Be the Outcomes?

In most countries, governments first reacted to demonstrations with the use of force, then cancelled the measures that had triggered the protests and announced alternative measures that did little to calm people’s minds. In Chile, for example, President Piñera initially declared that his country “was at war with an implacable enemy”, before apologizing for ignoring the extent of the inequalities that Chileans can no longer tolerate. He then announced a package of social measures, including an increase in the minimum wage. He finally scheduled a referendum for April 26, 2020, for Chileans to decide whether they want a new constitution. This political exit will not satisfy everyone, but at least it should allow the country to consider ending a 45-year cycle of neo-liberalism and build a more cohesive society.

Elsewhere, issues at stakes are more economic, but they are also societal. Feminist movements are waiting for concrete measures, particularly on abortion, but also for a change in mentality and practices. Their fight is a long-term one.

Footnotes

[1] “Education and engagement predict tolerance for anti-system protest” (LAPOP, insights series #139, 2019)

[2] Davies, James “Toward a theory of revolution”, American sociological review, 27(1), 1962

[3] According to the Pew research center.

[4] The gini index fell from 54.9 in 2000 to 47.6 in 2015. On the other hand, the share of national wealth captured by the ultra-rich has increased, which is something that marks public opinion (Desiguales. Orígenes, cambios y desafíos de la brecha social en Chile, UNDP, 2017).

English version by Miriam Périer (CERI) and Caitlin Gordon Walker.

Related links

More information

Paving the Way For A Green Future

Paving the Way For A Green Future

Eco-friendly, self-managed, and militant, PAVéS is an association committed to tackling questions on climate change at Sciences Po. But it is also well known by students for CAFéS, its ethical and solidarity-focused cafeteria run by students from the Paris campus. We met to talk with two of its members, Ilytie Piroit and Clémentine Sainclair, over an organic coffee. 

More
Yoga in Education: Tips on Stress Management

Yoga in Education: Tips on Stress Management

Sophie Flak, President of RYE France (Research on Yoga in Education) and lecturer at Sciences Po, has incorporated yoga breaks into her communication classes. In this video, she gives students tips to manage and help reduce stress, recenter focus, and aid concentration - tools that can be applied in academia as well as in the professional or personal realms.

More
FEMPO: Period-Proof Underwear Made in Sciences Po

FEMPO: Period-Proof Underwear Made in Sciences Po

FEMPO are the first period-proof underwear made in France. When Fanny Abes, at the time a third-year student in Vancouver, met Claudette Lovencin, the idea for the product was born. They are now both Sciences Po graduates. We met with them to speak about their career paths and business.

More
Ecological Transition: Sciences Po Launches a Three-Year Action Plan

Ecological Transition: Sciences Po Launches a Three-Year Action Plan

In the face of a climate in crisis and a planet experiencing profound ecological disruption, Sciences Po has set itself an ambitious three-year action plan. This plan will form one part of the much wider Climate Action: Make It Work initiative, launched in 2015. It responds to the institution’s obligations as both a place of study and work and a centre for teaching and learning, in Paris and across the six regional campuses.

More
Support for Fariba Adelkhah and Roland Marchal

Support for Fariba Adelkhah and Roland Marchal

Fariba Adelkhah and Roland Marchal, both researchers at the Sciences Po Center for International Studies (CERI), were arrested in Iran in early June 2019. Since then, they have been held in detention without valid legal grounds. On 31 January, 2020, the CERI organised a conference, "Captives Without Cause", aimed at contributing to the mobilisation for their release and raising awareness on the various issues (diplomatic, political, intellectual and human) linked to their detention. Many researchers, but also public figures familiar with the issue of arbitrary arrests and hostage situations were present.

More

"Rethinking International Relations"

Betrand Badie is the author of Rethinking International Relations, a thought-provoking book in which he argues that there has been a shift in the major IR paradigms and that ignorance of such transformation is a cause of conflict and instability. Professor Badie answers our questions on his understanding of the discipline, on its transformations, on issues of power and nostalgia…

More
Social Sciences Through the Prism of Gender

Social Sciences Through the Prism of Gender

PRESAGE, Sciences Po’s Research and Educational Programme on Gender Studies, was created in 2010. With the triple aim of promoting gender-related research, developing the university’s curriculum, and disseminating knowledge within the field, PRESAGE was among the first cross-cutting, interdisciplinary research programmes dedicated to gender studies in France. Meet its founders, Hélène Périvier et Françoise Milewski, both researchers at the Paris-based Observatoire français des conjonctures économiques (OFCE). 

More
Xiaorui Zhou, 2020 Rhodes scholar

Xiaorui Zhou, 2020 Rhodes scholar

Sciences Po undergraduate student Xiaorui Zhou is one of the four Chinese students to become a 2020 Rhodes scholar. This prestigious scholarship allows outstanding students to spend two years at the University of Oxford pursuing a postgraduate degree. Xiaorui is currently completing her double degree with Sciences Po and the National University of Singapore (NUS), majoring in History and Middle Eastern studies. She aspires to pursue two Master’s degrees at Oxford next year: one in Women’s Studies, and one in Contemporary Chinese Studies. Interview.

More