25/09/2018
09:00 19:00

LES ACTIVITÉS TRANSNATIONALES DES SERVICES DE RENSEIGNEMENT D'ORIGINE ÉLECTROMAGNÉTIQUE ET DIGITALE EN FRANCE ET EN EUROPE:
MUTATIONS EN COURS

25th of September 2018

9h00-10h30:  Panel 1 “Global Alliance, National Sovereignty: Sharing Secret Information Dilemmas” (in English)

Collaboration between SIGINT agencies over the world: a Global North alliance led by the 5 eyes and concentric circles or a transnational guild based on the capacity of extraction of information from internet sources

Chair:
Alex Macleod (Université du Québec à Montréal, Canada)

Participants:
Thorsten Wetzling (Stiftung Neue Verantwortung – SNV, Germany) – “Double Allegiance? The Case of the BND, a German Exception or a New Pattern”
Steven Loleski (Citizen Lab, University of Toronto, Canada) – "Bulk Collection, Targeted Attacks, and Global Surveillance: Interoperability and Operational Cooperation among the Five Eyes"
Ronja Kniep (Wissenschaftzentrum Berlin für Sozialforschung – WZB, Germany) – « Beyond the Five Eyes: the Limits of Sharing and Cooperation in Transnational Sigint Networks »
Didier Bigo (Sciences Po-CERI, France) - “The Transnational Guilds of Extraction of Information in the Field of Sensitive Intelligence”

Comments:
Andrew Neal (University of Edinburgh, UK) 

10h30-11h00: Coffee break

11h00-13h00: Panel 2 “Public-Private Assemblages and Resistance to Surveillance” (in English)

How has the relationship between large, consumer-facing tech companies (Google, Amazon, Facebook, Apple, Microsoft, etc.) with intelligence and law enforcement agencies evolved since 2013? Has civil society been successful in advancing the rule of law when it comes to secret state surveillance?

Chair:
Bertrand de la Chapelle (Internet & Jurisdiction Policy Network, Paris, France)

Participants:
Félix Tréguer (Institute for Communication Sciences - ISCC, France) – “(Re)Configuration of Public-Private Assemblages in Internet Surveillance (Case-Studies on the US and France)”
Matthias Schulze (Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik – SWP, Germany) - “Wannacry About the Tragedy of the Commons? Problems of Global Vulnerability Disclosure and Information Sharing”
Lina Dencik (Cardiff University, UK) – “Surveillance Realism, Resistance and the Limits of Techno-Legal Solutionism”
Grace Eden (Manchester Metropolitan University, UK) – “Cryptography, surveillance”

Comments:
Daniel Trottier (Erasmus University Rotterdam, The Netherlands)
Théodore Christakis (Centre d'Études sur la Sécurité Internationale et les Coopérations Européennes, Grenoble Alpes Data Institute)

13h00-14h30: Lunch

14h30-16h00: Panel 3 « Autorité et légitimité du renseignement : logiques d’actions des services dans la surveillance des étrangers et des citoyens » (en français)

Chair:
François Thuillier (ANR UTIC-CERI/Sciences Po)

Participants:
Laurent Bonelli (Université Paris Nanterre, France) – « Les processus d’enquêtes et leurs enjeux technologiques différentiés »
Bernard Voutat et Hervé Rayner (Université de Lausanne, Switzerland) – « Légitimité et contestation du renseignement : enseignements tirés du cas suisse »
Jean Paul Hanon (Écoles de Saint-Cyr Coëtquidan – ESCC, France) – « La fabrique du renseignement intégré en Allemagne »
Gilles Sainati (Tribunal de Grande Instance, Toulouse, France) – « Les interceptions de sécurité, le point de vue d’un juge »
Anthony Amicelle (Université de Montréal, Canada) – « L’autorité au quotidien des services de renseignement financier »

Comments:
Francesco Ragazzi (Leiden University, The Netherlands)

16h-16h30: Coffee break

16h30-18h00: Panel 4 “Extraction of Information and Human Rights: What Kind of Oversight?” (in English)

Intelligence operations may infringe human rights. How, in democratic regimes, to frame the limits? Are national oversights strong enough? In case of joint intelligence operations, what could be a transnational model of oversight?  

Chair :
Benoit Pelopidas (Sciences Po-CERI, France)

Participants:
Elspeth Guild (Queen Mary University of London – QMUL, UK) - “Antiterrorism and human rights in Europe, what kind of oversight?”
Félix Blanc (Fundaçao Getulio Vargas, Brasil) - « Extraterritorial Intelligence and Global Oversight »
Kilian Vieth (Stiftung Neue Verantwortung) - "Legal Safeguards and Oversight Innovation For Bulk Surveillance of Foreign Communications"
Rob Walker (University of Victoria) - "Liberties, Securities and the Delimitation of Intelligence?"

Comments:
Valsamis Mitsilegas (Queen Mary University)
Philippe Bonditti (Université Catholique de Lille)
 

18h00-19h00: Launch of the book “Antiterrorism and Human Rights” by Elspeth Guild and Didier Bigo

Commentary:
Laurent Bonelli (Université Paris Nanterre, France)
Kurt Graulich (former member of the German Federal Administrative Court, Humboldt University, Berlin, Germany)

Response :
Elspeth Guild (Queen Mary University of London – QMUL, UK)
Didier Bigo (Sciences Po-CERI, France)

 

 

                             Free registration here (subject to availability)

Organisé par : CERI